Trophic interaction modifications disrupt the structure and stability of food webs

Abstract

Trophic interaction modifications, where a consumer-resource interaction is influenced by an additional species, are established as being prevalent throughout ecological networks. Despite this, their influence on the structure of interaction distributions within communities has not yet been examined. Although empirical information about the distribution of interaction modifications is currently sparse, the non-trophic effects they induce will be structured by the underlying network of trophic interactions. Here we test the impact of interaction modifications, introduced under a range of distributional assumptions to artificial and empirical trophic networks, on the overall structure of interactions within communities. We show that local stability and reactivity is critically dependent on the inter-relationship between the trophic and non-trophic effects. Depending on their distribution, interaction modifications can generate significant additional structure to community interactions making analyses of the stability of ecological systems based solely on trophic networks unreliable. Empirical information on the topological and strength distributions of interaction modifications will be a key part of understanding the dynamics of communities.