No supergene despite social polymorphism in the big-headed ant Pheidole pallidula

Ant colonies ancestrally contained one queen and her non-reproductive workers. This is also the case for many but not all colonies of the Mediterranean big-headed ant Pheidole pallidula. Indeed, this species also has a derived form of social organization with multiple reproductive queens in the colony. The co-existence of two social forms also independently evolved in three other lineages of ants. In each of those lineages, variants of a supergene region of suppressed recombination determine social form. This is likely because supergene regions can link advantageous combinations of alleles from multiple loci. We thus hypothesized that a supergene region also determines colony queen number in the big-headed ant. To test this, we performed extensive population genetic analyses and genomic comparisons. We find no evidence of a supergene-like region with differentiation between single- and multiple-queen colonies. Our results show that a complex social polymorphism can evolve and be maintained without supergenes.